Two Great Visionaries
of Indian Music: Prof. Sambamurthy and Pandit V.N. Bhatkhande
Ashok Madhav – madhav_pgh@yahoo.com
Tireless efforts of the two men, who are responsible for revolutionizing
Indian classical music are Prof. Sambamurthy and Pandit V.N. Bhatkhande.
First let us see the contributions of Prof. P. Sambamurthy (1901-1973).
He had a modest life to begin with. Despite this, he had his musical training- in
vocal, violin and flute from Boddu Krishnaiah, Doraiswamy Iyer, S.A. Ramaswamy
Iyer and Krishnaswamy Bhagavatar. Further, he undertook formal training also in
Western music in Germany.
Prof. Sambamurthy visited many small towns and villages all
over South India including Tamil nadu, Karnataka, Andhra collecting information
on various music composers, musicians and also the technicalities of Carnatic
music. At Tanjavur District alone, he visited at least 60 villages to get the
information on musicians. He published 50 books on different aspects of
Carnatic music both in English and Tamil to benefit the music lovers. His
noteworthy contribution consists of books on South Indian Music in 6 volumes, Dictionary
of Music and Musicians, Moorchanakaraka melas and Amoorchanakaraka melas,
Variety of tala structures, Great Composers of Carnatic music and many more. His
books have been used both in the Universities as texts and as reference guides.
He has composed many kritis , one among them being on Saint Tyagaraja.
“The role of Prof. Sambamurthy as an outstanding
musicologist supersedes any other aspect of his genius, observes Prof.
SR.Janakiraman. He remarks that Prof. Sambamurthy deserves to be ranked alongside
of the great treatise-writers in music like Bharatha, Matanga, Ramamatya,
Venkatamakhin, Tulaja and Govinda of the past all rolled into one. He is the
architect of many concepts in musicology. He was the torch bearer and pioneer
in formulating a thematic scheme of study of musicology. Sangeeta Sampradya
Pradarshini of Subarama Dikshitar throws considerable light on the study of raga
lakshanas in great detail. Prof. Sambamurthy followed the lead of Subbarama
Dikshitar and expanded the subject exhaustively. He is the Sangeeta Sastra
Pitamaha of the 20 th century. Further, he hails him as ‘Ashadeera
dooradesamulanu prakasimpajesina sangita sastra sikhamani’.
He was a Professor of music at Madras University. He was
also associated with several universities like Venkateswara University,
Tirupathi, Mysore University, Benares Hindu University, Central College of
Carnatic Music, either as a visiting Professor or as an advisor.
Originally, he was trained as a lawyer with a degree in Law.
But his passion for Carnatic classical music was so much that he never
practiced law. He passed away when he was 72 years old. He was awarded Padma
Bhushan, Sangeetha Kalanidhi from the Music Academy and Sangeet Natak Akademi
fellowship.
On the contrary, Pandit Vishnu Narayan Bhatkhande (1860-
1936) did much to systematize Hindustani music against all odds. In his early
years, he learnt vocal singing and playing on veena and flute from various
teachers - Raojiba, Belbagkar, Ali Hussain Khan and Vilayat Hussain Khan. Later
on he enrolled himself in a college and graduated with a degree in law and
practiced law for a brief while.
He travelled to several North Indian cities like Pune,
Baroda, Ajmer, Gwalior, Agra, Rampur, Benares etc. and he met with many music
ustads and pundits, collected enormous data and like a modern Venkatamakhin, he
devised a unique system to classify Hindustani ragas. There were pockets of
music schools all over the North India practicing their own styles of music.
There were hardly any communications between different schools. The Hindustani music
has been undergoing drastic changes over the decades and the music documented earlier
has become obsolete.
Prof.Bhatkhande also went to many South Indian towns and
cities like Tanjavur, Tirunelveli, Madurai, Bangalore, Mysore, Chennai etc. With
the information collected from both North and South Indian centers, he devised
“Thaat” system of classification of Hindustani ragas similar to the
Venkatamakhin’s Melakarta system of Carnatic music. Prof. Bhatkhande gave a
broad base and put in almost 90- 95 % of the existing Hindustani ragas of his
time under the “thaat" system. Prof. Bhatkhande defined ragas the easy way
to understand and composed several bandishes (similar to small kritis) to
explain arohanam and avarohanam of the ragas. Before this approach, Hindustani
music was practiced in different centers in various ways with no reference to
each other.
Prof. Bhatkande is to the North, what Venkatamakhin is to
the South, in revolutionizing Hindustani Sangeet. Scholars have eulogized his
pioneering efforts. He published several books on music to bring an order. His
monumental work is “Hindustani Sangeet Paddhati” in 4 volumes. He also prepared
a valuable treatise, the Hindustani Sangeet Kramik Pustak Maalika as text
books. These books have become standard texts in many Universities. He held
Professorship in a few Universities. He established Colleges of Music in
Lucknow and Gwalior. He died in 1936 and he was 76.
India has many musicians, a few composers and a fewer musicologists.
When the westerners are eager to learn Indian system of music, and if
authoritative books are not available, music cannot get its proper exposure. Musicology
as a discipline should not end with Prof. Sambamurthy and Prof. Bhatkhande
alone.